If I were to rate the books individually they would start at five stars and end at zero. The last book or two were so fudging bad that it was a chore to finish them. Skylar became so obnoxious and insufferable to listen to. Logan becomes an emo 13 year old. All the best characters are murdered and new characters are brought in to be killed off ten seconds later. There is zero description of scenery. The narrator broke his back carrying this heap.