The first book of the five is soo confusing and not bundled properly with the characters, the main guy would just not give up his work. I was ready to drop the book but have it one more try with book two. I must say each book got better the last two were really good that’s why I gave it a 3. The reader was outstanding and kept me with the book . Overall the last 3 books were nice to great love stories and I did enjoy them.