Honestly, I enjoyed this series for the most part In. And that says a lot considering it’s length but when it came to Grays Shadow I began to despise the characters to the point where I didn’t want to continue. I genuinely would have preferred to have Gray leave the club. And that happening literally right before the ending plays a part in making me not want to continue because the other club members were so unlikable. I loved Beast and Laurence in the first book, and couldn’t wait to read the last to get to them again, but by the fourth I hated them. I also don’t feel that Grays story ended as well as the others before. Besides that I loved Shadows character.